Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Florida Politics

Special Session for More Tort Reform?

Guest Op-Ed by Jim Kallinger

For over a couple of decades, Florida was listed on the annual “Judicial Hellholes” report produced by the American Tort Reform Association.  But little by little, under the leadership of Gov. Ron DeSantis, that began to change.  In the spring legislative session of 2023, the Florida legislature finally pulled together a significant lawsuit reform package, and now, our state is no longer listed as a judicial hellhole.  

However, we are still a state on the watchlist, and that is not good.  It is also disappointing that we were not able to take the next steps in the 2024 legislative session to address the third-party lawsuit financing issue and medical malpractice.  If we had, we might very well have been removed from the watchlist.

Third-party financing of a lawsuit sounds like a good idea, with the argument being that it gives some people without the ability to pay for their own expenses during a lawsuit recovery period the opportunity to get a loan to keep a lawsuit going.  The idea is that without the financing, an injured party might be too willing to take a much smaller settlement just to get some quick cash.

However, this potential benefit is being abused.  Third party financiers will often keep lawsuits going even if the plaintiff wants to accept a settlement.  Financiers can and have taken over decisions on the direction of the case, ignoring any consideration for the paintiff.  Financiers can and have charged exorbitant interest rates to the point that even after victory, a plaintiff may receive little to nothing from a final settlement or award.  Even more alarming is that financial third-party funds can and have been set up to receive funding from international investors, including foreign governments.  Even the thought that international profiteers could be using our courts system to attack our small businessmen and women in Florida should be enough to question this system.  Proposed legislation would have required disclosures to the judge and jury about third-party financing to the court.  It is likely that juries would be far less generous with some of the frivolous claims for non-economic damages if they knew that the money would be going to a corporate investor instead of the injured party sitting in the courtroom.  In some ways, the plaintiff would have already received his or her payout in the form of the loan or advance from the third party.  Giving the third party a bonus for making the loan does not seem to make sense.

Another effort in the last legislative session that was not successful was to provide caps on awards for non-economic damages for medical malpractice.  Non-economic damages don’t relate to actual damage but to claimed emotional damage.  For instance, a botched minor surgery with a tiny amount of true economic damage may be simultaneously paired with a massive claim for emotional distress.  In Florida, there have even been instances of parents collecting on pain and suffering for adult children and instances of adult children collecting on pain and suffering for the deaths of parents.  The proposed legislation would not have eliminated all claims for non-economic damages, but it would provide for reasonable caps that would have installed more predictability to the system.  

The legislature missed an opportunity.  I would suggest that they need to come back in for a special session.  We get the legal environment right, and Florida’s economy will never slow down.

Share Story Via Text, E-Mail, Facebook or Twitter

Follow Us on Social Media

Related Stories

Florida Democratic Party

It could be described as an “October Surprise.” A new report by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) details how thousands of illegal immigrants...

Florida Politics

All elected Republican Jacksonville City Council members, except for one, voted to send the city into millions of dollars of new debt, which may...

Florida Politics

The new laws set to begin this week all originated from bills passed this year the state session. Some the new laws include: HB...

Florida Democratic Party

Florida State Senator Lauren Book has been on a mission, and that is to empower survivors of domestic violence. Beginning October 1 – the...

Abortion

GUEST OPINION EDITORIAL by Zack Smith Limiting governmental intrusion sounds great. Right? Protecting the health of mothers. Who would object to that? That’s how...

Crime

New polling this year reveals that public support for local police is up, as is voter trust. Lexipol compiled several surveys of voters’ attitudes...

Economy

At a recent roundtable on condo costs, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis heard pleas from condo owners on large assessments they are facing due to...

Elections

This November, Amendment 3 will be on the Florida ballot, proposing a radical change to our state’s drug policies and making recreational marijuana legal....