Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Opinion

Instead of Firing Football Coaches, UF & FSU Football Should Push for Reforms to Transfer Portal, NIL

Three weeks into the 2024 NCAA Football season, two of Florida’s “Big Three” traditional powers are already out of contention for a bid at a bid in the College Football Playoff. Florida State University head coach Mike Norvell and University of Florida head coach Billy Napier have been the primary recipients of heavy criticism from fans of their respective teams. Both coaches know that the passionate calls for new leadership come with the territory, but fans should step back and look at a much bigger factor: Name, Image and Likeness (NIL) deals and the transfer portal.

Since college football was created, its fans have cherished player loyalty to their school. Until NIL and the transfer portal were introduced, coaches and fans could count on the vast majority of players to stay at their school for their entire college year, with the exception of a few players who may declare a year or two early for the NFL Draft.

Today, a college team’s roster may undergo more changes each offseason than any NFL franchise. To appease student-athletes, the NCAA allowed them to enter the transfer portal even in crucial stretches of the season, such as the gap between the final regular season games and the postseason. As a result, the product suffers, with dozens of players opting to transfer to a new school or sit out of a bowl game to avoid an injury, which could ultimately impact the amount of money they may make from the team’s NIL collective.

Billy Napier

Consider Napier’s position with the Gators’ quarterback depth chart. Graham Metzger, a transfer from Wisconsin, has his own NIL deal, but the Gators’ backup, D.J. Lagway, could be a much better fit for his offense.

If Napier benches a quarterback who came to UF via the transfer portal, the Gators may not be able to attract future talent through the portal.

Norvell faces a similar scenario at FSU, where a senior quarterback transferred from Oregon State. DJ Uiagalelei came to the team via the transfer portal, and was expected to be among the nation’s elite quarterbacks. Younger quarterbacks recruited by FSU could have started and developed their skills. Instead, was given the reins as the starter, then struggled in each start as FSU lost each of its first three games.

Mike Norvell

Now, Norvell has to decide between sticking with Uiagalelei and all the NIL supporters who pledged their money to him or a home-grown quarterback who didn’t receive as much early acclaim or NIL funding but could ultimately produce better results and change the trajectory of the Seminoles’ long-term outlook.

Even though elite college programs will consistently successfully recruit and sign exceptionally talented athletes, the inevitable instability and roster fluctuations caused by the transfer portal and NIL make it virtually impossible for any team to avoid a season where more games are lost than anyone initially expects. Flaws in the new system were glaringly obvious this past bowl season, as several teams saw their rosters dramatically changed due to players putting their individual income above the overall best interests of their respective teams.

Bowl games outside of the College Football Playoff will continue to lose value and sponsors unless reforms are made to incentivize players to finish a season. Teams in the Group of 5 (The conferences that aren’t among the NCAA’s Power 5 Conferences) are already at a significant disadvantage when it comes to corporate sponsorships and media contracts. If non-playoff bowl games eventually go extinct, the only incentive for players will be a conference championship.

College football coaches have plenty of faults, but athletic directors, fans, and NCAA administrators need to consider all of the consequences of NIL and the trade portal before the sport they love becomes unrecognizable from the one they cherished for decades.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

By Matt O’Hern

Author

  • Matt O'Hern

    Matt O’Hern’s journalism experience includes 20 years of reporting and consulting for various news outlets in Florida and Alabama. O’Hern earned his journalism degree from Samford University in Birmingham, Alabama. View all posts

Share Story Via Text, E-Mail, Facebook or Twitter

Follow Us on Social Media

Related Stories

Crime

Marion County Sheriff’s Office (MCSO) Major Crimes Detective Henrik Osthed arrested 58-year-old Carl Philip Lombardo for Human Trafficking of a Child for Commercial Sexual...

Entertainment

Recent reports from the New York Post, cinema bloggers, and British tabloids cite an anonymous source stating that a sequel to “The Goonies,” a 1985 adventure film,...

Story 2

Earlier this summer, Florida Daily reported that the Biden administration was planning to expand Obamacare to illegal immigrants. Now Florida is leading the legal...

Business

Florida’s high school student athletes will be able to earn income for their name, image and likeness used in advertising. Multiple news sources, such...

Most Recent

The Jacksonville Jaguars recently announced a massive renovation plan for its EverBank Stadium. The project is slated to cost around $1.4 billion in total....

Most Recent

Fan Owned Club, one of the pioneering organizations involved in creating the fan owner movement in sport has announced that North Florida-based government affairs...

Epic Universe

Update provided by Matt O’Hern Universal Orlando Resort revealed more details about How to Train Your Dragon – Isle of Berk. It will be...

Most Recent

By Matt O’Hern Disney Cruise Line Revealed the name and theme of its next ship, sailing in 2025. The Disney Destiny, which is the...